---
title: California Orders Uber and Lyft to Pay their Drivers Under State Law
description: "\"Uber and Lyft must comply with state law AB5 and classify all of their drivers as employees rather than contractors.\""
image: https://blog.plrisk.com/hubfs/paul-hanaoka-D-qq7W751vs-unsplash.jpg
---

[![2012 PLRisk Logo-Feb-28-2023-09-30-45-0928-PM](https://blog.plrisk.com/hs-fs/hubfs/2012%20PLRisk%20Logo-Feb-28-2023-09-30-45-0928-PM.png?width=1650&height=500&name=2012%20PLRisk%20Logo-Feb-28-2023-09-30-45-0928-PM.png "2012 PLRisk Logo-Feb-28-2023-09-30-45-0928-PM")](https://plrisk.com/)

[![PL Risk](https://blog.plrisk.com/hs-fs/hubfs/raw_assets/public/Pl_Risk_June_2020/images/plrisk-50x140-logo.png?width=300&height=300&name=plrisk-50x140-logo.png "PL Risk")](https://plrisk.com/)

- [HOME](https://plrisk.com/)
- [CUSTOMER CENTER](https://plrisk.com/#) 
    - [Make A Payment](https://plrisk.epaypolicy.com/)
    - [Submit An Application](https://www.plrisk.com/applications/)
    - [Confirmation of Coverage](mailto:info@plrisk.com)
    - [Download Applications](https://plrisk.com/applications)
    - [File a Claim](https://plrisk.com/file-a-claim)
    - [Claim Scenarios](https://plrisk.com/claim-scenarios)
    - [FAQs](https://plrisk.com/faqs)
    - [Industry Tools](https://plrisk.com/industry-tools)
    - [Free Cyber Hotline](https://plrisk.com/free-cyber-hotline)
    - [Get Appointed](https://plrisk.com/for-agents)
- [INDUSTRIES WE SERVE](https://plrisk.com/#) 
    - [Architects & Engineers](https://plrisk.com/architects-engineers/)
    - [Financial Institutions](https://plrisk.com/financial-institutions/)
    - [Healthcare / Medical](https://plrisk.com/healthcare-medical/)
    - [Insurance](https://plrisk.com/insurance/)
    - [Technology](https://plrisk.com/technology/)
    - [Consulting](https://plrisk.com/consulting/)
    - [Legal](https://plrisk.com/legal)
    - [Real Estate](https://plrisk.com/real-estate/)
    - [Media](https://plrisk.com/media)
    - [Miscellaneous Services](https://plrisk.com/miscellaneous-services/)
- [PRODUCTS](https://plrisk.com/#) 
    - [Overview](https://plrisk.com/products)
    - [Errors and Omissions](https://plrisk.com/products/errors-omissions)
    - [Directors and Officers](https://plrisk.com/products/directors-officers/)
    - [Commercial Crime](https://plrisk.com/products/commercial-crime/)
    - [Employment Practices](https://plrisk.com/products/employment-practices/)
    - [Cybersecurity](https://plrisk.com/products/fiduciary/)
    - [Fiduciary](https://plrisk.com/products/cybersecurity/)
- MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS 
    - [Reps and Warranties Sell](https://www.plrisk.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/PLR-Reps-and-Warranties-SellSide-Onesheet.pdf)
    - [Reps and Warranties](https://www.plrisk.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/PLR-Reps-and-Warranties-Onesheet.pdf)
- CANNABIS 
    - [Overview](https://www.plrisk.com/products/cannabis-insurance)
    - [Account Highlights](https://blog.plrisk.com/hubfs/PLR%20-%20Cannabis%20Assets/PLR-CANNABIS-account%20highlights_Onesheet-V2.pdf)
    - [Commercial Property](https://www.plrisk.com/cannabis-commercial-property/)
    - [Commercial Crime](https://www.plrisk.com/cannabis-business-insurance-commercial-crime)
    - [Cyber Liability](https://www.plrisk.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/PLR-12-CANNABIS-Cyber-Insurance-Onesheet-V8.pdf)
    - [D&O](https://blog.plrisk.com/hubfs/PLR%20-%20Cannabis%20Assets/PLR-CANNABIS-D%26O-Onesheet-V1.pdf)
    - [E&O](https://blog.plrisk.com/hubfs/PLR%20-%20Cannabis%20Assets/PLR-CANNABIS-E%26O-Onesheet-V1.pdf)
    - [EPLI](https://www.plrisk.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/PLR-10-CANNABIS-Employment-Practices-Liability-Onesheet-V9.pdf)
    - [General Liability](https://www.plrisk.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/PLR-02-CANNABIS-General-Liability-Onesheet-V4-1.pdf)
    - [Product Liability](https://www.plrisk.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/PLR-03-CANNABIS-Product-Liability-Onesheet-V2-4.pdf)
    - [Workers’ Comp](https://www.plrisk.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/PLR-05-CANNABIS-Workers-Compensation-Onesheet-Reduced.pdf)
- [SELECT](https://www.plrisk.com/products/select-division/)
- [ABOUT](https://plrisk.com/#) 
    - [Our Team](https://plrisk.com/our-team/)
    - [Careers](https://www.plrisk.com/careers/)
    - [Our Charity](https://plrisk.com/helping-hands/)
- NEWSROOM 
    - [Blog](https://blog.plrisk.com)
    - [Newsletters](https://www.plrisk.com/plr-newsletters/)
- QUOTE ONLINE 
    - [Hiscox NOW Small Business Insurance](https://www.hiscox.com/partner-agent/plriskadvisors)
    - [Custom Quote](https://www.hiscox.com/partner-agent/plriskadvisors)

- CUSTOMER  
  CENTER
  
  
  
    - [MAKE A PAYMENT](https://plrisk.epaypolicy.com/)
    - [SUBMIT AN APPLICATION](https://www.plrisk.com/applications/)
    - [CONFIRMATION OF COVERAGE](mailto:info@plrisk.com)
    - [DOWNLOAD APPLICATIONS](https://plrisk.com/applications)
    - [FILE A CLAIM](https://plrisk.com/file-a-claim)
    - [CLAIM SCENARIOS](https://plrisk.com/claim-scenarios)
    - [FAQs](https://plrisk.com/faqs)
    - [INDUSTRY TOOLS](https://plrisk.com/industry-tools)
    - [FREE CYBER HOTLINE](https://plrisk.com/free-cyber-hotline)
    - [GET APPOINTED](https://plrisk.com/for-agents)
- INDUSTRIES  
  WE SERVE
  
  
  
    - [TITLE AGENTS & MORTGAGE BROKERS](https://www.plrisk.com/real-estate/)
    - [REAL ESTATE](https://www.plrisk.com/real-estate/)
    - [LEGAL](https://www.plrisk.com/legal/)
    - [MEDIA](https://www.plrisk.com/media/)
    - [ARCHITECTS & ENGINEERS](https://www.plrisk.com/architects-engineers/)
    - [FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS](https://www.plrisk.com/financial-institutions/)
    - [CONSULTING](https://www.plrisk.com/consulting/)
    - [MISC. SERVICES](https://www.plrisk.com/miscellaneous-services/)
    - [HEALTHCARE MEDICAL](https://www.plrisk.com/healthcare-medical/)
    - [INSURANCE](https://www.plrisk.com/insurance/)
    - [TECHNOLOGY](https://www.plrisk.com/technology/)
    - [SPACs](https://www.plrisk.com/spacs/)
- PRODUCTS
  
  
  
    - [PRODUCTS OVERVIEW](https://plrisk.com/products)
    - [Errors & Omissions](https://plrisk.com/products/errors-omissions)
    - [Directors & Officers](https://plrisk.com/products/directors-officers/)
    - [Commercial Crime](https://plrisk.com/products/commercial-crime/)
    - [EPLI](https://plrisk.com/products/employment-practices/)
    - [Fiduciary Liability](https://plrisk.com/products/fiduciary/)
    - [Cybersecurity](https://plrisk.com/products/cybersecurity/)
- [MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS](https://www.plrisk.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/PLR-Managing-Insurance-Coverage-eBook-03272023.pdf)
  
  
  
    - [Reps and Warranties](https://www.plrisk.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/PLR-Reps-and-Warranties-Onesheet.pdf)
    - [Reps and Warranties Sell](https://www.plrisk.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/PLR-Reps-and-Warranties-SellSide-Onesheet.pdf)
- [CANNABIS](https://www.plrisk.com/products/cannabis-insurance)
  
  
  
    - [Overview](https://www.plrisk.com/products/cannabis-insurance)
    - [Account Highlights](https://blog.plrisk.com/hubfs/PLR%20-%20Cannabis%20Assets/PLR-CANNABIS-account%20highlights_Onesheet-V2.pdf)
    - [Commercial Crime](https://www.plrisk.com/cannabis-business-insurance-commercial-crime)
    - [Commercial Property](https://www.plrisk.com/cannabis-commercial-property/)
    - [Cyber Liability](https://www.plrisk.com/cannabis-business-insurance-cyber-liability/)
    - [D&O](https://www.plrisk.com/cannabis-directors-officers-do-liability/)
    - [E&O](https://www.plrisk.com/cannabis-errors-omissions-eo/)
    - [EPLI](https://www.plrisk.com/cannabis-employment-practices-liability/)
    - [General Liability](https://www.plrisk.com/cannabis-general-liability/)
    - [Product Liability](https://www.plrisk.com/cannabis-product-liability/)
    - [Workers’ Comp](https://www.plrisk.com/cannabis-business-insurance-workers-compensation/)
- [SELECT](https://www.plrisk.com/products/select-division/)
- ABOUT
  
  
  
    - [Our Team](https://plrisk.com/about-us/)
    - [Our Charity](https://plrisk.com/helping-hands/)
    - [Careers](https://www.plrisk.com/careers/)
- NEWSROOM
  
  
  
    - [BLOG](https://blog.plrisk.com)
    - [NEWSLETTERS](https://www.plrisk.com/plr-newsletters/)
- QUOTE  
  ONLINE
  
  
  
    - [Hiscox NOW Small Business Insurance](https://www.hiscox.com/partner-agent/plriskadvisors)
    - [Custom Quote](https://www.hiscox.com/partner-agent/plriskadvisors)

×

### Get A Quote

# California Orders Uber and Lyft to Pay their Drivers Under State Law

[Drew Smith](https://blog.plrisk.com/author/drew-smith)

 Oct 27, 2020, 9:45:00 AM

![](https://blog.plrisk.com/hubfs/paul-hanaoka-D-qq7W751vs-unsplash.jpg)

![paul-hanaoka-D-qq7W751vs-unsplash](https://blog.plrisk.com/hs-fs/hubfs/paul-hanaoka-D-qq7W751vs-unsplash.jpg?width=4651&name=paul-hanaoka-D-qq7W751vs-unsplash.jpg)

In a surprising move, the State of California has ruled that the ride sharing services, Uber and Lyft must comply with [state law AB5](https://www.wsj.com/articles/uber-and-lyft-must-classify-drivers-as-employees-appeals-court-says-11603416727?mod=business_lead_pos2) and classify all of their drivers as employees rather than contractors. Prior to this, the drivers had been considered independent contractors that could set when they were on the clock or not.

Uber and Lyft had long contended that because these drivers had contracts that were flexible on when they could clock in, they were listed as independent contractors. Critics contend that this is not the case. Governor Jerry Newsom has replied that they use this idea to dodge paying their workers wages and not complying with state regulations. Unions have also criticized them because contractors can’t join their unions.

A three-judge panel ruled that these drivers should be considered employees and the companies have to pay these costs. One judge wrote, “We recognize that defendants’ business models are different from that traditionally associated with employment, particularly with regard to drivers’ freedom to work as many or as few hours as they wish, when and where they choose, and their ability to work on multiple apps at the same time."

The judges noted that nothing is preventing these drivers from using both services as their jobs, which many do so. “The panel nevertheless argued the companies were employers because the ride-sharing service they provided was the core of their business model, rather than an incidental activity, pointing to a Supreme Court ruling called Dynamex. As for the possibility that the companies cannot function as traditional employers, the panel asserted that just couldn’t possibly be true.”[\[1\]](https://blog.plrisk.com/california-orders-uber-and-lyft-to-pay-their-drivers-under-state-law#_ftn1)

Because of these rulings, both Uber and Lyft have considered leaving the state to avoid paying their drivers. With regards to contractors and employees, consult your state’s laws on where the line is.

[\[1\]](https://blog.plrisk.com/california-orders-uber-and-lyft-to-pay-their-drivers-under-state-law#_ftnref1) [https://www.nationalreview.com/2020/10/court-ruling-could-kill-uber-and-lyft-in-california/](https://www.nationalreview.com/2020/10/court-ruling-could-kill-uber-and-lyft-in-california/)

## Recent Posts

- [Tracking Cookies Beginning to Run Afoul of Consumer Data Protection Laws](https://blog.plrisk.com/tracking-cookies-beginning-to-run-afoul-of-consumer-data-protection-laws)
- [PLRisk welcomes Jeffery Phi to their growing Wholesale Broker roster](https://blog.plrisk.com/plrisk-welcomes-jeffery-phi-to-their-growing-wholesale-broker-roster)
- [PLRisk Welcomes Michelle Delaney as Wholesale Account Manager](https://blog.plrisk.com/plrisk-welcomes-michelle-delany-as-wholesale-account-manager)
- [PLRisk Spotlights Rachel Coughlin](https://blog.plrisk.com/plrisk-spotlights-rachael-coughlin)
- [PLRisk congratulates Matt Culkin on joining NJYIP Board](https://blog.plrisk.com/plrisk-congratulates-matt-culkin-on-joining-njyip-board)

Search

### Share this post

[![Share on facebook](https://7528309.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hub/7528309/hubfs/raw_assets/public/mV0_d-web-default-modules_hubspot/img/facebook-color.png?width=24&name=facebook-color.png)](http://www.facebook.com/share.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.plrisk.com%2Fcalifornia-orders-uber-and-lyft-to-pay-their-drivers-under-state-law%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_source%3Dfacebook) [![Share on linkedin](https://7528302.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hub/7528302/hubfs/raw_assets/public/mV0_d-web-default-modules_hubspot/img/linkedin-color.png?width=24&name=linkedin-color.png)](http://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.plrisk.com%2Fcalifornia-orders-uber-and-lyft-to-pay-their-drivers-under-state-law%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_source%3Dlinkedin) [![Share on twitter](https://7528302.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hub/7528302/hubfs/raw_assets/public/mV0_d-web-default-modules_hubspot/img/x-twitter-color.png?width=24&name=x-twitter-color.png)](https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?original_referer=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.plrisk.com%2Fcalifornia-orders-uber-and-lyft-to-pay-their-drivers-under-state-law%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_source%3Dtwitter&url=https%3A%2F%2Fblog.plrisk.com%2Fcalifornia-orders-uber-and-lyft-to-pay-their-drivers-under-state-law%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_source%3Dtwitter&source=tweetbutton&text=) [![Share on email](https://7528311.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hub/7528311/hubfs/raw_assets/public/mV0_d-web-default-modules_hubspot/img/email-color.png?width=24&name=email-color.png)](mailto:?subject=Check%20out%20https%3A%2F%2Fblog.plrisk.com%2Fcalifornia-orders-uber-and-lyft-to-pay-their-drivers-under-state-law%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_source%3Demail%20&body=Check%20out%20https%3A%2F%2Fblog.plrisk.com%2Fcalifornia-orders-uber-and-lyft-to-pay-their-drivers-under-state-law%3Futm_medium%3Dsocial%26utm_source%3Demail)

### Subscribe to our blog

[![PLRisk-LogoWhite](https://blog.plrisk.com/hs-fs/hubfs/PLRisk-LogoWhite.png?width=400&height=123&name=PLRisk-LogoWhite.png "PLRisk-LogoWhite")](https://plrisk.com/)

### Stay connected to learn the latest from PLRisk

By clicking submit I agree to the  [Privacy Policy](https://www.plrisk.com/privacy-policy)  and [Terms & Conditions.](https://www.plrisk.com/terms-conditions/)

###### 795 Franklin Avenue, Suite 210 Franklin Lakes, NJ 07417 Tel: (855) 403-5982 Fax: 201-847-9174

- RESOURCES 
    - [DOWNLOAD APPLICATIONS](https://plrisk.com/applications)
    - [FILE A CLAIM](https://plrisk.com/file-a-claim)
    - [CLAIM SCENARIOS](https://plrisk.com/claim-scenarios)
    - [FAQs](https://plrisk.com/faqs)
    - [INDUSTRY TOOLS](https://plrisk.com/industry-tools)
    - [FREE CYBER HOTLINE](https://plrisk.com/free-cyber-hotline)
    - [GET APPOINTED](https://plrisk.com/for-agents)
- PRODUCTS 
    - [PRODUCTS OVERVIEW](https://plrisk.com/products)
    - [ERRORS & OMISSIONS](https://plrisk.com/products/errors-omissions)
    - [DIRECTORS & OFFICERS](https://plrisk.com/products/directors-officers/)
    - [COMMERCIAL CRIME](https://plrisk.com/products/commercial-crime/)
    - [EMPLOYMENT PRACTICES](https://plrisk.com/products/employment-practices/)
    - [FIDUCIARY LIABILITY](https://plrisk.com/products/fiduciary/)
    - [CYBERSECURITY](https://plrisk.com/products/cybersecurity/)
- PROFESSIONS 
    - [TITLE AGENTS & MORTGAGE BROKERS](https://plrisk.com/real-estate/)
    - [REAL ESTATE](https://plrisk.com/real-estate/)
    - [LEGAL](https://plrisk.com/legal)
    - [MEDIA](https://plrisk.com/media)
    - [ARCHITECTS & ENGINEERS](https://plrisk.com/architects-engineers/)
    - [FINANCIAL INST.](https://plrisk.com/financial-institutions/)
    - [CONSULTING](https://plrisk.com/consulting/)
    - [MISC. SERVICES](https://plrisk.com/miscellaneous-services/)
    - [HEALTHCARE/MEDICAL](https://plrisk.com/healthcare-medical/)
    - [INSURANCE](https://plrisk.com/insurance/)
    - [TECHNOLOGY](https://plrisk.com/technology/)
- ABOUT 
    - [OUR TEAM](https://www.plrisk.com/about-us/)
    - [BLOG](https://blog.plrisk.com/)
    - [OUR CHARITY](https://plrisk.com/helping-hands/)
    - [CAREERS](https://www.plrisk.com/careers/)
    - [PRIVACY POLICY](https://www.plrisk.com/privacy-policy)
    - [TERMS & CONDITIONS](https://www.plrisk.com/terms-conditions/)
    - [ACCESSIBILITY STATEMENT](https://www.plrisk.com/accessibility-statement/)
    - [STATE LICENSES](https://www.plrisk.com/state-licenses/)

Copyright © 2023 PLRisk | All Rights Reserved | [Privacy Policy](https://www.plrisk.com/privacy-policy)

PLRisk Specialty Insurance Agency LLC is a licensed insurance broker legally operating in the state of New Jersey under license number NJ 3002329782 and in California DBA NJ PLRisk Specialty Insurance Agency LLC, License number CA 6009937